The Virginia Department of Wildlife Resources expects construction on a new Lake Shenandoah dam to begin in late spring of 2027. The old dam, built in 1956, will be demolished completely, and a replacement will go up 150 feet upstream. At the September public meeting, DWR said the job would take 12 months and wrap up by the end of 2027, WHSV reported.
For Magnolia Ridge, the lake down the road beside Lakeview Golf Club gets one more winter in its current form. Once the dam is rebuilt, the water will be higher than it is now. DWR's own drawings also show it covering a smaller area than it did before it was lowered.
Three Water Lines on One Drawing
The 1.5-mile loop trail around the lake today follows a shoreline that has been held down on purpose. DWR gives two accounts of why. Its Lake Shenandoah page describes a flood that damaged the emergency spillway on the north side of the dam. After that, the Department of Conservation and Recreation's Dam Safety Division required the lake to be lowered about 5 feet from full pool. The September 2026 press release describes a large seepage area found at the toe of the dam in 2020, with boring samples showing degraded material in the dam's core. Both accounts end the same way, with a lake about five feet low and a dam that has to be replaced.
The engineering exhibit DWR posted, dated September 24, 2026, puts the three versions of the lake side by side:
| Version of the lake | Normal pool elevation | Normal pool area |
|---|---|---|
| Before the lowering, labeled "prior to 2018" | 1,295.5 feet | 38.39 acres |
| Today, labeled "post 2018" | 1,290.58 feet | not listed |
| Proposed after the new dam | 1,293.4 feet | 28.0 acres |
Working from those figures, the proposed pool sits about 2.8 feet above today's water and about 2.1 feet below the old normal pool. DWR's press release describes the new level as "approximately one foot from pre-lowering pool height." The release and the drawing don't line up on that point, and the drawing has the more precise numbers. The area figures change the picture more than the elevations do. DWR calls Lake Shenandoah a 36-acre impoundment. The exhibit lists 38.39 acres at the old normal pool and 28.0 acres at the proposed one.
Much of the lake is already shallow, under 3 feet, with a maximum depth near the dam of 25 feet. In a lake that shallow, a couple of feet of elevation moves the waterline across a lot of ground. That's how the rebuilt lake can be higher than today's and still noticeably smaller than the original.
Why the Plan Was Redrawn
The current design is DWR's second try. In October 2024, the agency showed residents a different plan. That version moved the dam 322 feet upstream, kept the pool slightly below the level at the time, and set a December 2026 finish, according to WHSV's coverage of that meeting. Many people at that meeting raised concerns about the upstream move and the lower water.
The 2024 plan's schedule would have had construction nearly finished by now. Instead, the community's reaction sent the project back for redesign. State Sen. Mark Obenshain described what happened at this September's meeting, as reported by WHSV:
"We had a meeting like this about a year ago to show what 3 million dollars was going to do. There was great disappointment in the community, and the result of that was going back to the drawing board and figuring out how to do it better. How to do it in a way that will make the community proud."
DWR's release says the same thing in agency language. After hearing from the public, it worked with consultant engineers on a plan to maximize pool levels while meeting state dam safety regulations, made possible by additional state funding. The redesign cut the upstream move from 322 feet to 150 and won back some of the water level. Neighbors also lost a year of schedule in exchange, which is part of why the current lake is getting another winter at all.
What Late Spring 2027 Starts
The September release says the project is in the planning and permitting phase, and it gives only a season for the start of work. Obenshain told WHSV that his biggest concern is construction delays pushing the finish date later.
DWR has not yet published how the 2026 design will affect the water, the trail, or the boat ramp during construction. The 2024 plan spelled that out for its version: the lake would be fully lowered during construction, some trails would be partially closed for equipment and materials, and the boat ramps and fishing piers would be moved. That plan has been replaced, so its construction details describe the project residents turned down, not necessarily the one being built. The contact for project questions listed on the DWR Lake Shenandoah page is John Kirk, DWR's Capital Programs Manager.
Two things are certain. The dam you can see from the trail today is the one being torn down. And between now and late spring, nothing on the posted schedule changes the lake.
The Ducks Arrive Before the Excavators
That leaves the lake's best birding season untouched. At the September meeting, attendee Diane Lepkowski told WHSV the lake draws migrating birds and that "in the winter a lot of nice ducks come down from up north." The Rockingham Bird Club's newsletter records from last season back her up.
- November 16, 2025: Great Egrets at the lake
- November 20, 2025: Red-breasted Mergansers
- December 6, 2025: a club bird walk led by Greg Moyers, meeting in the lake parking lot at 8:30 a.m.
- March 23, 2026: two dozen scaup along with grebes, mergansers, Ruddy Ducks, Buffleheads and Wood Ducks
The club's October 2026 newsletter doesn't list a Lake Shenandoah outing yet. The club's field trips are open to members and guests, so keep an eye on the Goldfinch Gazette for a winter date. Ducks haven't come down yet as of this week. An eBird checklist from October 24, 2026 logged 18 species at the lake, mostly woodland and field birds such as Pileated Woodpecker, Eastern Bluebird, Ruby-crowned Kinglet, Swamp Sparrow and Yellow-rumped Warbler.
The loop is also built for this kind of watching. The pollinator trail starts on the west side of the parking lot, runs through a restored stretch replanted with native wildflowers and grasses, and has interpretive signs about the habitat along the way. At the meeting, Lepkowski also said she hopes the project keeps or replaces that bird habitat, from the undergrowth to the pollinator trails. That shoreline is the one that will move after the rebuild.
Before Your Next Walk
Lake Shenandoah is a DWR-owned public fishing lake, and its rules are stricter than a county park's.
- Access permit. Visitors 17 and older need a DWR Access Permit unless they hold a valid Virginia hunting, freshwater fishing or trapping license or a current Virginia boat registration. The daily permit is $4 per person and the annual permit is $28, both including the $1 license agent fee. You can buy either through DWR's licensing page or by calling 1-866-721-6911. The Rockingham Bird Club also lists Restore the Wild membership as accepted for entry. Seven daily permits add up to the price of the annual one, so the annual permit comes out ahead starting with the eighth visit.
- Hours. Fishing is allowed from one hour before sunrise to one hour after sunset. All other activities are limited to daylight hours.
- On the water. Paddle craft and electric motors are allowed. Gasoline motors, swimming, wading, ice skating, hunting, camping and alcohol are not.
- Fishing expectations. DWR has stopped stocking channel catfish until further notice and says catch rates should drop over time. Largemouth bass, bluegill, crappie, carp and musky are also in the lake. Musky under 40 inches must be released.
- Facilities. There's a large gravel lot, a gravel boat ramp, restrooms and a bait hut run by Baits, Boats and Bobbers, which also rents kayaks. The bait hut is seasonal, so don't count on it being open on a January morning.
Permit rules and fees are set by DWR and can change. This is general information, not legal advice, so check DWR's access permit page for current terms before you go.
Our agents at Nest Realty Harrisonburg keep track of changes like the Lake Shenandoah rebuild because they shape daily life around Magnolia Ridge. If you'd like to talk through how the project might affect your part of the county, we're glad to help.